Cakes
We offer a variety of cake flavors, fillings, and frostings. We can customize your order to accommodate your event, guest list, and theme. We also provide a limited selection of our own favorite creations.
Cake Flavors
**If you are looking for a particular flavor that you do not see listed, please reach out. We will try our best to accommodate your needs.**
Classic Fillings:
Buttercream: Vanilla, Chocolate
Premium Fillings:
(available at an extra charge)
Buttercream: Cream Cheese, Peanut Butter, Oreo, Marshmallow, Citrus
Dulce de Leche
Ganache: Milk Chocolate, White Chocolate, Dark Chocolate
Andy's Sweet Shoppe Signature Cakes:
(6" - $70 8"-$90, 10"-$110)
Triple Chocolate - Chocolate cake layers, filled with chocolate ganache, topped with chocolate buttercream and a chocolate ganache drip
Oreo - Layers of Oreo cake, filled with chocolate ganache, frosted with Oreo buttercream topped with Oreo cookies
Peanut Butter Cup - Chocolate cake layers, filled and frosted with peanut butter buttercream, topped with chocolate ganache drip and decorated with Reese's peanut butter cups
Premium Cake Flavors:
(available at an extra charge)
Confetti
Carrot
Red Velvet
Seasonal
Classic Cake Flavors:
Chocolate
Vanilla
Strawberry
Lemon
Almond
Pricing
Each Cake Tier Has 3 Layers
3 layers of cake with filling and/or frosting between
All starting prices and serving size suggestions are listed under the Cake Type
*exact cake dimensions may slightly vary*
Mini / Smash / Anniversary
4 inches wide and 5 inches tall
Perfect for 2 people!
Available in Chocolate or Vanilla Cake only.
Starting at $40
Small Single
6 inches wide and 6 inches tall
Serves about 12-1”x 2” slices
Starting at $60
Small Double
6”wide x 6” tall top tier; 8”wide x 6” tall bottom tier
Serves about 36-1”x 2” slices
Starting at $150
Medium Single
8 inches wide and 6 inches tall
Serves about 24-1”x 2” slices
Starting at $80
Medium Double
8”wide x 6” tall top tier; 10”wide x 6” tall bottom tier
Serves about 62-1”x 2” slices
Starting at $190
Large Single
10 inches wide by 6 inches tall
Serves about 38-1”x 2” slices
Starting at $100
Large Double
10” wide x 6” tall top tier; 12”wide x 6” tall bottom tier
Serves about 94-1”x 2” slices
Starting at $230
Small Triple
6”wide x 6” tall top tier; 8”wide x 6” tall middle tier; 10” wide X 6” tall bottom tier
Serves about 74-1”x 2” slices
contact for pricing
Medium Triple
8”wide x 6” tall top tier; 10”wide x 6” tall middle tier; 12” wide X 6” tall bottom tier
Serves about 118-1”x 2” slices
contact for pricing
Large Triple
10”wide x 6” tall top tier; 12”wide x 6” tall middle tier; 14” wide X 6” tall bottom tier
Serves about 172-1”x 2” slices
contact for pricing